(Nach Position in alphabetischer Reihenfolge)
| Endet | Fred Biletnikoff, Florida St. |
| Jack Snow, Notre Dame | |
| Tackles | Larry Kramer, Nebraska |
| Ralph Neely, Oklahoma | |
| Wachen | Rick Redman, Washington |
| Glenn Ressler, Penn St. | |
| Center | Dick Butkus, Illinois |
| Rücken | Lawrence Elkins, Baylor |
| Tucker Frederickson, Auburn | |
| John Huarte, Notre Dame | |
| Gale Sayers, Kansas |
